Skip to main content
Auto Insurance

Average Cost of Car Insurance by Credit Score (2026)

2026 national estimates show average premiums of $2,578 with good credit, $3,280 with fair credit, and $5,478 with poor credit. Credit use is restricted in some states; review state rules before applying this comparison locally.

See your personalized rate estimate

Our calculator factors in your credit tier, state, age, and driving history.

Auto Insurance Calculator →

$2,578/yr

Good credit

2026 national average

$3,280/yr

Fair credit

2026 national average

$5,478/yr

Poor credit

2026 national average

2026 Car Insurance Rates by Credit Tier

Credit TierAnnual Avg.Monthly Avg.vs. Good Credit
Good$2,578$215/moBaseline
Fair$3,280$273/mo+27%
Poor$5,478$457/mo+112%

2026 national average premiums by credit tier. State rules vary; California, Hawaii, Massachusetts and Michigan restrict or prohibit credit-based insurance scoring. Source: Insurance.com.

Rate Impact Visualized

Good
$215/mo
Fair
$273/mo
Poor
$457/mo

How to Lower Your Rate by Improving Credit

✓Pay every bill on time — payment history is 35% of your credit score
✓Pay down credit card balances below 30% utilization
✓Don't close old accounts — length of credit history matters
✓Dispute errors on your credit report (check annualcreditreport.com)
✓Avoid opening multiple new accounts in a short period
✓Ask your insurer to re-run your credit score at renewal after improvements
Note: Credit-based insurance rules vary by state and can change. Check current state law and ask the insurer whether this factor applies to your quote.

How Credit Score Affects Your Car Insurance Rate

Insurers don't use your FICO score directly — they use a credit-based insurance score. Here's exactly how it works.

  1. 1

    Insurer pulls a credit-based insurance score

    When you apply or renew, the insurer pulls a credit-based insurance score (CBIS) from LexisNexis or Equifax. This is a soft pull — it does not affect your credit score. The CBIS is correlated with your FICO score but weighted differently: payment history and collections matter most; available credit matters less.

  2. 2

    Insurer applies its own rating approach

    Tier names and premium impacts vary by insurer and state. The national averages in the table are not fixed multipliers and should not be used to predict an individual quote.

  3. 3

    Credit-based information interacts with other factors

    Location, age, driving history, vehicle, coverage and insurer pricing all also affect the quote. A national credit-tier average cannot isolate the effect for an individual applicant.

  4. 4

    State rules are checked

    State rules restrict or prohibit credit-based insurance scoring in some jurisdictions. Verify current requirements with your state insurance department or insurer.

  5. 5

    Score is re-checked at renewal

    Most insurers re-pull your credit score at each annual renewal. If your score has improved significantly, your rate should decrease at the next renewal. You can also ask your insurer to re-run your score mid-term if you've made major improvements — some will do this as a courtesy.

Methodology note: Rates on this page are for a 35-year-old with a clean record, averaged across states that permit credit-based pricing. Actual impact varies by insurer and state. Get quotes from multiple insurers — credit weighting differs significantly between companies.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does credit affect car insurance rates?

Where permitted, insurers may use credit-based insurance information. The rules and premium impact vary by state and carrier.

How much can I save by improving my credit?

The difference between national credit-tier averages does not predict an individual's savings. Ask your insurer how state rules and its rating plan apply to your policy.

What credit score do I need for the best car insurance rates?

Insurers use differing credit-based insurance scores and rating plans; a consumer credit-score threshold is not universal. Ask the carrier how its system works.

Which states restrict credit-based insurance scoring?

State rules vary and can change. Check your state insurance department or ask your insurer for current restrictions before relying on a national comparison.