Progressive vs. Allstate: 2026 National Sample Averages
The cited 2026 national sample averages are lower for Progressive by about 17%. Your own quote may differ by state, vehicle, driver profile and underwriting.
National sample premium comparison
Progressive: $2,675/yr. Allstate: $3,205/yr.
Source: Insurance.com 2026 rate analysis. These are modeled national averages, not personalized quotes.
Progressive vs. Allstate: Key Differences
Progressive
Best known for its Snapshot telematics and competitive rates for high-risk drivers.
Strengths
- ✓Snapshot telematics can cut rates 10–20% for safe drivers
- ✓Competitive for drivers with prior accidents
- ✓Name Your Price tool helps budget-conscious shoppers
- ✓Strong rideshare coverage options
Watch Out For
- ✗Rates can be high for drivers who don't use telematics
- ✗Customer satisfaction scores trail State Farm
Allstate
Full-service insurer with a large agent network and broad coverage options.
Strengths
- ✓Drivewise telematics rewards safe driving
- ✓Broad coverage add-ons (rideshare, sound system, etc.)
- ✓Large local agent network
- ✓Accident forgiveness available
Watch Out For
- ✗Among the most expensive of the major insurers
- ✗Mixed customer satisfaction in claims handling
Bottom Line: Which Should You Choose?
Neither insurer is universally cheaper — it depends on your state, age, driving history, and credit score. Progressive wins nationally by ~17%, but Allstate can be cheaper in specific states and for certain driver profiles. The only way to know for sure is to get quotes from both.
Estimate Your Rate First →Frequently Asked Questions
- Is Progressive or Allstate cheaper for auto insurance?
- Progressive is cheaper nationally, averaging $2,675/year vs. $3,205/year for Allstate — about 17% less. These national modeled averages do not predict which insurer will be cheaper for your profile; compare matched quotes.
- What is Progressive best for?
- Drivers with prior accidents or tickets who want usage-based savings.
- What is Allstate best for?
- Drivers who want comprehensive coverage and local agent support.
- How do I choose between Progressive and Allstate?
- Get quotes from both for your specific ZIP code and driver profile. Pricing can vary by state and underwriting. Estimate your rate first →