Auto Insurance · Columbus, OH · ZIP 43209
Calculate My Rate →
Compare Quotes →
Car Insurance in 43209 (Bexley, Columbus) — 2026 Rates
Drivers in ZIP code 43209 (Bexley) pay an average of $1,739/yr for full coverage — -6% vs. Columbus avg. Affluent suburb, lower theft.
ZIP 43209 Avg
$1,739/yr
Monthly Est.
$145/mo
Min Coverage From
$639/yr
Columbus City Avg
$1,850/yr
How ZIP 43209 Compares
| Area | Annual Rate | Monthly | vs. ZIP 43209 |
|---|---|---|---|
| ZIP 43209 — Bexley | $1,739 | $145/mo | This ZIP |
| Columbus City Average | $1,850 | $154/mo | +6% cheaper |
| Ohio State Average | $1,795 | $150/mo | +3% cheaper |
Get your personalized rate for ZIP 43209
ZIP code averages are a starting point — your rate also depends on your age, driving record, and vehicle.
Car Insurance Rates in ZIP 43209 by Driver Profile
| Driver Profile | Annual Rate | Monthly Est. | vs. ZIP Avg |
|---|---|---|---|
| Clean record, 35yo | $1,739 | $145/mo | 0% |
| One at-fault accident | $2,491 | $208/mo | +43% |
| DUI on record | $3,760 | $313/mo | +116% |
| Teen driver (18yo) | $3,525 | $294/mo | +103% |
| Senior (65yo) | $1,861 | $155/mo | +7% |
Full coverage estimates for Bexley (43209). Rates vary by insurer and individual factors.
Why Rates in 43209 Are Below the Columbus Average
ZIP-specific factor
Affluent suburb, lower theft
•
Icy roads and winter weather accidents
•
Moderate traffic congestion
•
Tornado risk in central Ohio
•
Moderate uninsured driver rate (~12%)
Cheapest Car Insurance Near ZIP 43209
Lowest Rate Found
Progressive
Starting around $1,128/yr for a clean-record driver in Bexley