Skip to main content

Car Insurance Rates in New York City, New York (2025)

Drivers in New York City pay an average of $3,820/yr for full coverage car insurance — +43% vs. NY avg. The cheapest option starts around $1,650/yr for minimum coverage.

Full Coverage Avg

$3,820/yr

Monthly Est.

$318/mo

Min Coverage From

$1,650/yr

NY State Avg

$2,679/yr

Get your personalized New York City rate

City averages are a starting point — your rate depends on your age, driving record, and vehicle.

Calculate My Rate →

New York City Car Insurance Rates by Driver Profile

Driver ProfileAnnual RateMonthly Est.vs. City Avg
Clean record, 35yo$3,820$318/mo0%
One at-fault accident$5,400$450/mo+41%
DUI on record$7,800$650/mo+104%
Teen driver (18yo)$7,200$600/mo+88%
Senior (65yo)$4,100$342/mo+7%

Full coverage estimates for New York City. Rates vary by insurer, ZIP code, and individual factors.

Cheapest Car Insurance in New York City

Lowest Rate Found

Progressive

Starting around $2,400/yr for a clean-record driver

Compare Quotes →

Why Car Insurance Is Expensive in New York City

•

Highest density traffic in the US

•

No-fault insurance state (PIP required)

•

High auto theft and vandalism rates

•

Expensive auto repair labor market

Car Insurance Rates by ZIP Code in New York City

Rates vary significantly by neighborhood. Click any ZIP code to see detailed rates for that area.

ZIP CodeNeighborhoodEst. Annual Ratevs. City Avg
10001Midtown Manhattan$4,890/yr+28%View details →
10036Times Square/Hell's Kitchen$4,775/yr+25%View details →
10014West Village$4,393/yr+15%View details →
10128Upper East Side$4,202/yr+10%View details →
11201Brooklyn Heights$4,126/yr+8%View details →
11368Corona, Queens$4,508/yr+18%View details →
10314Staten Island$3,667/yr-4%View details →
10461Bronx$4,660/yr+22%View details →

Estimates based on city average adjusted for ZIP-level risk factors. Actual rates vary by insurer and driver profile.

Related Tools & Guides