Skip to main content
Auto Insurance Review 2025

Acuity Insurance Auto Insurance Review (2025)

Top-rated regional insurer in the Midwest — exceptional service.

Overall Rating
4.3/5
AM Best: A+ (Superior)J.D. Power: N/AAvg. Rate: $2,160/yrComplaint Index: 0.42(1.0 = avg)

Founded

1925

HQ

Sheboygan, WI

Market Share

0.4%

Avg. Annual Rate

$2,160

Category Scores

Price
4.2/5
Claims
4.5/5
Customer Service
4.6/5
Coverage Options
4.1/5
Digital Experience
3.6/5

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • ✓One of the lowest complaint indexes in the industry
  • ✓Exceptional claims and customer service
  • ✓Competitive rates in Midwest
  • ✓Strong independent agent relationships

Cons

  • ✗Only available in 26 states
  • ✗Must purchase through independent agent
  • ✗Digital tools are limited

Who Is Acuity Insurance Best For?

Best For

  • →Midwest residents
  • →Drivers who prioritize service quality

Not Ideal For

  • →Drivers outside Acuity's service area
  • →Digital-first customers

Sample Rates by Driver Profile

Estimates based on publicly available rate data. Your rate will vary by state, vehicle, and coverage selection.

Driver ProfileEst. Annual RateEst. Monthly
35-year-old, clean record, good credit, full coverage$2,160$180/mo
25-year-old, clean record, good credit, full coverage$2,790$233/mo
35-year-old, one at-fault accident, full coverage$3,010$251/mo
35-year-old, clean record, poor credit, full coverage$3,420$285/mo
35-year-old, clean record, good credit, liability only$790$66/mo

Coverage Options

✓Liability
✓Collision
✓Comprehensive
✓Uninsured Motorist
✓Medical Payments
✓Rental Reimbursement
✓Roadside Assistance
✓Rideshare Coverage

Available Discounts

Multi-policyMulti-vehicleGood studentLoyaltyAnti-theftPay-in-fullPaperless

How Acuity Insurance Calculates Your Auto Insurance Rate

Acuity uses an independent agent model with a strong focus on service quality. Its mutual structure and conservative underwriting result in excellent claims outcomes.

How does Acuity Insurance calculate auto insurance rates?Why does Acuity have such a low complaint index?What states does Acuity Insurance serve?Is Acuity Insurance good for claims?

1. Independent agent quoting

Acuity is sold through independent agents who can compare it against other carriers.

2. Conservative underwriting

Acuity's careful risk selection results in a very low complaint index and strong claims satisfaction.

3. Mutual company benefits

As a mutual insurer, Acuity's profits benefit policyholders.

Acuity Insurance FAQ

What states does Acuity serve?

Acuity serves 26 states primarily in the Midwest and Mountain West.

Why does Acuity have such a low complaint index?

Acuity's mutual structure and strong agent relationships create a culture focused on policyholder satisfaction.

Methodology: Ratings and average rates are based on publicly available rate filings, J.D. Power studies, AM Best ratings, and industry data. Average rates shown are for a 35-year-old driver with a clean record, good credit, and full coverage. Your rate will vary.

Ready to Compare Your Rate?

Use our free calculator to estimate what you'd pay with Acuity Insurance and other top insurers based on your profile.

Estimate My Auto Insurance Rate →

More Insurer Reviews